Best Margaritas in Southern Indiana

This page will be updated as I work to sample the areas margaritas.


Pelicanos comes in at #1 on the Best Margarita list. We paid $18.99 for a pitcher. Served with orange and an umbrella. The margaritas were so good we came back the next day for another pitcher.

Fireside Grill

Patty’s Margarita comes in at #2. Stop in on Saturday and the drink is $5.50. Tastes like a pure and simple Margarita. Ordered with sugar.

Ramiro’s Cantina Express

#3 is a tasty margarita in downtown Jeffersonville. We ordered the Top Shelf margarita made with Number Juan tequila. $6.99

Pints & Union

My #4 is the Union Margarita. Made with Lunazul Blanco tequila, agave, lime & orange. $9. Very good but a little pricey compared to others on the list.

Pearl Street Taphouse

#5 – Ordered with Patron. This Margarita included some orange juice. The Margarita as is cost us $9.50 each.